Petit steps down from SZV board due to ‘undue influence’ from Lee

~ Lee: allegations seems political, wants evidence ~

PHILIPSBURG–“Over reaching and undue influence” from Public Health Minister Emil Lee is one of the reasons gynaecologist Dr. Michel Petit gave as factors for stepping down as Chairperson of the Supervisory Board of Directors of Social Health Insurance SZV.

Petit intends to file a complaint with the Public Prosecutor’s Office and the National Detectives to “protect” himself from future claims associated with his previous responsibilities as chairman of the board.

In reaction to Petit’s allegations, Lee said the lack of prior discussion and timing of Petit’s release gives his actions “a suspiciously political flavour.” He urged Petit to provide evidence that he (Lee) has in anyway exerted inappropriate influence over the supervisory board and implementing body, an allegation the minister “takes extremely seriously… I find it strange that during my time in office Dr. Petit has not written one letter to me indicating that he was of the opinion that I was exerting undue and over-reaching influence on the board, and chooses to do so with no prior discussion via the media,” Lee said in a release issued hours after Petit’s release.

“Last week, during the farewell party for Dr. Petit at SZV he mentioned to everyone that he was leaving to pursue his true passion medicine, and to be able to devote more time to his practice in Anguilla. He never made any comment or gave any indication similar to the sentiment reflected in his press release.”

Petit’s resignation became effective as of Monday, August 15. He joined the board in 2011 and became chairman in December 2014.

“I resigned because I could no longer dedicate the time that would have been needed to accomplish my stipulated tasks due to the over-reaching and undue influence of the Minister of Public Health and Social Affairs on the Supervisory Board, and on the implementing body of the organisation and the time required to reign in the management to follow proper procedures as is stipulated by law would be too time consuming,” Petit said in a press release issued on Sunday, several days after The Daily Herald sought his comments on the resignation.

“Under those circumstances, it was not possible for me to function effectively in accordance with the law, as such I made the hard and regrettable decision to resign from this vital organisation that has tremendous health, social and financial responsibility,” Petit said.

The seasoned healthcare professional said based on the country’s Civil Code, supervisory directors can be held personally liable for mismanagement of funds. “I was made aware by the press of inappropriate actions of the implementing body of the organisation. Due to this legal reason, I will file a formal complaint with the Office of the Public Prosecutor (and the) National Detectives to protect myself from future claims because these actions were done under my watch, and also to protect my integrity and respected personal image,” he said.

In the meantime, Lee said: “Exerting undue influence is contrary to all the principles of good governance to which I subscribe. A number of letters have been sent to Dr. Petit identifying where the supervisory board, in my opinion, has been deficient in their tasks and responsibilities. However, those letters requesting that the Board of SZV improve their compliance as required by law could hardly constitute undue influence. I will be reviewing Dr. Petit’s comments and/or accusations in more detail over the next days with legal advisors and will respond accordingly.”

Petit said residents who “worked hard” their entire lives to have something to look

forward to when they reach pension age deserve to have their pension fund used following proper procedures and in a “prudent manner” knowing that a national decree based on the old age pension law LAOV regarding investment of the AOV funds was never issued.

He said SZV is an independent administrative body that has an implementing structure with a corporate personality. Its independence covers its internal organisation, management of its resources and the representation of its interest. SZV is primarily responsible for the execution of the social and health insurances of St. Maarten. To accomplish this mission SZV is under the leadership of a director and deputy director assisted by a management team and supervised by a supervisory board.

The director, Petit said, is charged with the management of the financial resources of the organisation and is competent to act in these matters by law. He is also accountable by law to the Minister of Public Health and Social Affairs. The supervisory board supervises the general course of events of the organisation and monitors its funds, properties and other resources entrusted to the organisation.

By law, the director adopts rules after hearing the supervisory board. These regulations are complementary to the SZV ordinance and should be published on SZV’s website, Petit said.

   “The rules governing the director clearly state that the implementing body will be managed by a director under the supervision of a supervisory board, and to allow the supervisory board to carry out its task as stated in Article 7, Paragraph 3 of the rules regulating the functioning of the director. The director shall timely notify the supervisory board of such information on facts and circumstances regarding the implementing body of the organisation which the board may need as required by law to properly carry out its tasks,” he said.

Source: Daily Herald
Petit steps down from SZV board due to ‘undue influence’ from Lee


  1. What peculiar timing Dr. Petit! You were about to retire and now to please Theo you trying to throw a wrench in the mix. Disgusting!

  2. This article raises an interesting question. It doesn’t have anything to do with the Minister or Dr. Petit. It does have to do with investment guidelines. The problem is that between the CFT and the Netherlands the SXM government can borrow at 2% interest. Sounds great and it probably is in the short term. It does create severe distortions in the financial market. It Caps interest at 2%. These means funds like the AOV cannot really invest at higher rates. Chances are the calculations of the health of the fund use higher percentages. It also means that people who try to save for their retirement on their own have a hard time finding good investments that will pay a fair rate of interest. Actually they’ll have hard time outpacing inflation.

    Our 101010 debt relief and the resulting 2% provision can be termed bubble finance. It creates distortion in the market and prevents savers ( and their funds) from getting fair value, pushing them into riskier investments. It allows government to borrow at rates that are much lower than their track record of deficit spending would have them. 6 years on from 101010, very little has been done to address the structural issues that got us such a huge public debt in the first place.

    With an antiquated fiscal system. global financial bubbles and no way to insulate ourselves from larger countries public finance shenanigans. The last thing we should be doing is literally forcing local funds to search for return outside the market.

    The probability of this resulting in a world of hurt for future generations and retirees a couple of years down the line is just too large to be neglected.

      • Actually, I don’t have any inside knowledge at all, really don’t want to either. Just a very good understanding of monetary policy and market distortions. I don’t really care who runs the show as long as they prudent. The unfortunate thing is that there is no return in being prudent anymore. Remember when you could get a decent percentage on a CD or even your savings account? Those days are over. With a large fund like the SVB unable to get a good rate of return by purchasing government bonds, who knows they mart start doing things like buying buildings and issues short term loans. Imagine the relationship if they invested directly into the hospital. It would be extremely hard to do that without creating a conflict of interest.